Spooky Spots in Blount County

Written by: Emily Huffstetler

Do you believe in ghosts? According to a recent poll, about 39% of Americans do. While Southern Appalachia has become a trending ghost-hunting hotspot on TikTok, the Peaceful Side of the Smokies seems—well, peaceful. You won’t hear many ghost stories floating around Blount County. But in the spirit of Halloween, here are a few local legends. 

Maryville College 

At over two centuries old, Maryville College is one of the oldest institutions of higher education in the country. Students and faculty alike whisper about the campus’s otherworldly residents, whose legends have been passed down through old issues of The Highland Echo and Alpha Psi Omega ghost tours. 

The most famous of these spirits is Whiskers, said to roam the halls of Anderson Hall, the oldest building on campus. Described as an elderly man with a peg leg, Whiskers is forever searching for his missing limb. Some say he was a Civil War soldier who lost his leg in battle, while others claim he was an old night watchman who never truly clocked out.

Then there’s Lily, the theatre ghost. Long ago, when Maryville College Theatre stood where the Clayton Center is now, Lily was said to be a stagehand with dreams of stepping into the spotlight. Her spirit reportedly lingers in the catwalks above the stage—sometimes seen as a flicker of white just before showtime. 

Other tales include a restless female student in Pearsons Hall, who reportedly haunts the building where her dorm once stood, and the Woman in White who drifts through the upper floors of the House in the Woods, combing her long hair as she gazes out the windows. 

Millenium Manor 

On North Wright Road in Alcoa stands one of Blount County’s strangest and most enduring landmarks, Millennium Manor. Built by William Andrew Nicholson beginning in 1937, the gray marble house was designed to last forever. A skilled mason, Nicholson worked days at the Alcoa plant and nights on his home, hauling 300-pound stones by wheelbarrow and stacking them into fourteen rooms of Roman arches and keystones. 

Nicholson believed the house would survive the end of the world and shelter his family during the thousand-year reign of Christ foretold in the Book of Revelation. He once said his fortress “cannot rust or rot, and if nothing wrecks it, there is no reason why it shouldn’t last a million years.” 

When his wife, Fair, died in 1950, Nicholson kept building, convinced his faith would spare him from death. He passed away in 1965, never seeing the Millennium he expected. Over time, rumors grew that he had buried his wife within the walls, though her marked grave suggests otherwise. 

Locals still tell of flickering lights, echoing footsteps and faces in the windows. Some believe Nicholson’s spirit remains inside the house he swore would outlive him. When current owner Dean Fontaine was once asked if the manor is haunted, he simply replied, “We don’t talk about that.” 

Millenium Manor is on the National Register of Historic Places and is open to the public from noon to 5 p.m. on weekends. 

__________________________________________________________________________________________________

Born and raised in Maryville, Tennessee, with roots tracing back to Cades Cove, Emily Huffstetler is a proud Maryville College graduate and passionate storyteller of the Greater Smokies region.